Mental Models for the Negation of Conjunctions and Disjunctions

Guillermo Macbeth, Eugenia Razumiejczyk, María del Carmen Crivello, Claudia Bolzán, Carolina Iris Pereyra Girardi, Guillermo Campitelli

Abstract


This study investigates why reasoning that involves negation is extremely difficult. We presented participants with reasoning problems containing sentences with negation of conjunctions and disjunctions in order to test predictions derived from the Mental Models Theory of human thought. According to this theory, reasoning consists of representing and comparing possibilities. Different sentential forms would require different cognitive demands. In particular, responses to a sentential negation task would be modulated by working memory load. This prediction would hold for correct responses but also for the general pattern of responses that includes incorrect responses when the task offers different response options. A within-subjects experimental design with selection paradigm was applied to test these predictions. Experimental comparisons and a complementary descriptive study yielded evidence consistent with the theory-driven predictions derived from the Mental Models Theory. The working memory load was critical for the modulation of correct responses and overall responses. We discussed alternative accounts, and suggested additional predictions for further evaluation of these phenomena.


Keywords


mental models; sentential reasoning; negation; conjunction; disjunction; working memory

Full Text: PDF HTML

https://doi.org/10.5964/ejop.v10i1.696

Citing articles (via Crossref)

  • Miguel López-Astorga (2016)
    Mental Logic and the Denials of Conjunctions and Disjunctions
    Trans/Form/Ação, 39(1), p. 119(ff.)
    doi: 10.1590/s0101-31732016000100007
  • Guillermo Eduardo Macbeth, María del Carmen Crivello, Mauro Bruno Fioramonti, Eugenia Razumiejczyk (2017)
    Chronometrical Evidence Supports the Model Theory of Negation
    SAGE Open, 7(2), p. 215824401771621(ff.)
    doi: 10.1177/2158244017716216
  • Sangeet Khemlani, Isabel Orenes, P.N. Johnson-Laird (2014)
    The negations of conjunctions, conditionals, and disjunctions
    Acta Psychologica, 151, p. 1(ff.)
    doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2014.05.004
  • Guillermo Campitelli, Guillermo Macbeth, Raydonal Ospina, Fernando Marmolejo-Ramos (2017)
    Three Strategies for the Critical Use of Statistical Methods in Psychological Research
    Educational and Psychological Measurement, 77(5), p. 881(ff.)
    doi: 10.1177/0013164416668234