No Occasion for Pleasure: The Self-Worth Contingency of a Setback and Coping With Humor


  • Fay Caroline Mary Geisler
  • Vera Loureiro de Assunção


Whether or not one uses humor to cope with a setback may depend on the idiosyncratic relation of the setback to feeling of self-worth. All people pursue the higher order goal of self-validation, but people differ in what domains of life their self-worth is contingent upon and to what extent. In this article based on an incongruity theory of humor we argue that the use of humor in coping with a highly self-worth-contingent setback may be impeded by two cognitive-motivational processes: goal-driven activation and goal shielding. From the outlined theory we derived the hypothesis that the more a domain is contingent upon self-worth, the less likely a person will be to use humor to deal with a setback in that domain. We tested this hypothesis in two studies employing two forms of self-report, i.e., ratings of reaction likelihood to setbacks described at an abstract domain level (Study 1), and ranking of reaction likelihood to concrete setbacks from different domains (Study 2). The hypothesis was affirmed in different domains of self-worth contingency controlling for the influence of habitual coping with humor, coping by disengagement, and global self-esteem.

Author Biographies

Fay Caroline Mary Geisler, Department of Psychology, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, <country>Germany</country>
Fay Geisler holds a long-term appointment at the University of Greifswald where she received her doctorate degree in psychology. She teaches personality psychology and psychological assessment and works as a cognitive-behavioral therapist. Her research focuses on self-regulation, emotion regulation, and self-control.
Vera Loureiro de Assunção, Department of Psychology, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, <country>Germany</country>
Vera Loureiro de Assunção is a research assistant at the University of Greifswald. She studied in Lisbon and Greifswald and received her diploma in psychology at the University of Greifwald. Her research focuses on the emotion regulation strategy reappraisal. She is currently writing her Ph.D. thesis.